Template:Tyrone All Stars record

Tyrone has 57 All Stars, as of 2021. 33 different players have won, as of 2021. Peter Canavan and Seán Cavanagh won eleven All Stars between them.   denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.

1980: Kevin McCabe
1984: Eugene McKenna, Frank McGuigan
1986: John Lynch, Plunkett Donaghy, Damien O'Hagan, Eugene McKenna^2nd
1989: Eugene McKenna^3rd
1994: Peter Canavan
1995: Fay Devlin,  Peter Canavan ^2nd
1996: Finbar McConnell, Peter Canavan^3rd
2001: Stephen O'Neill
2002: Peter Canavan^4th
2003: Cormac McAnallen, Conor Gormley, Philip Jordan, Seán Cavanagh, Brian Dooher, Brian McGuigan, Peter Canavan^5th
2004: Seán Cavanagh^2nd
2005: Ryan McMenamin, Conor Gormley^2nd, Philip Jordan^2nd, Seán Cavanagh^3rd, Brian Dooher^2nd, Peter Canavan^6th, Owen Mulligan,  Stephen O'Neill ^2nd
2008: Conor Gormley^3rd, Justin McMahon, David Harte, Philip Jordan^3rd, Enda McGinley, Brian Dooher^3rd,  Seán Cavanagh ^4th
2009: Stephen O'Neill^3rd
2010: Philip Jordan^4th
2013: Seán Cavanagh^5th
2015: Mattie Donnelly
2016: Mattie Donnelly^2nd, Peter Harte
2017: Colm Cavanagh
2018: Colm Cavanagh^2nd, Pádraig Hampsey
2019: Ronan McNamee, Cathal McShane
2021: Niall Morgan, Pádraig Hampsey^2nd, Conor Meyler,  Kieran McGeary , Peter Harte^2nd, Brian Kennedy, Niall Sludden, Darren McCurry